The Race of Twilight

14 Jun

Although Middle Earth is full of monsters that are highly original, Tolkien also introduces us to some fairly familiar foes: the trolls from The Hobbit, for example, are quite traditional in the way they are depicted. Although it must be said, by the standards of most trolls in mythology and fantasy, the three encountered by Bilbo Baggins in The Hobbit were mental giants. Bert, William and Tom spoke and understood the tongue of men and had an elementary, if faulty, knowledge of arithmetic. They were, none the less, turned to stone as a result of the quickness of wit of the wizard Gandalf and in this they conformed to myth and legend in more than one way. For the idea that trolls “must be underground before dawn, or they go back to the stuff of the mountains they are made of” is an ancient one, with the god Odin playing the same trick as Gandalf in the Old Norse poem Alvissmal. Elsewhere, again in keeping with Scandinavian trolls, Tolkien tells us that “In their beginning far back in the twilight of Elder Days, these were creatures of dull and lumpish nature and had no more language than beasts”. Like orcs, Tolkien’s trolls were bred by the artifice of the first Dark Lord Morgoth, and were his own twisted version of the noble race of Ents. But trolls were rightly feared, for they were twice the height and bulk of the greatest men, had skin of green scales like armour and they desired most a diet of raw flesh. As if that were not bad enough, by the time of The Lord of the Rings a troll-race not before seen appeared in Middle Earth – one that, unlike the older race of twilight, could even endure the sun.


In Scandinavia, Trolls were believed to be giants, and the biggest of them all was Dovregubben (their king in the mountain Dovre). They were shaggy and rough-haired, with trees and moss-like growth on their heads and noses. Their noses were long and they would sometimes stir with them when cooking broth or porridge. Some even had two or three heads (Tolkien admits to the possibility of this in Middle-Earth when he states that “trolls do behave like that, even those with only one head each” in The Hobbit). Their features differed from humans with four fingers and four toes and a tail resembling that of a cow. Legend places them as guardians of bridges and byways, though their help seems arbitrary and dubious. The trolls of Norse mythology lived hundreds of years, only dying if turned to stone by sunlight. Although fearsome, interestingly, Norse trolls did not favour eating man-flesh – their preferred meat of choice was mutton (perhaps Tolkien was remembering this when he called the chapter in which Bilbo encounters Bert, William and Tom Roast Mutton!). As well as being ever-present in German and Scandinavian folklore, trolls are also found in the fairy tales of Finland, Russia and the British Isles – most notably Grendel from the Anglo-Saxon poem Beowulf.

Beowulf’s quest is to find and destroy Grendel, who has been attacking the mead-hall of Heorot, killing and eating anyone he finds there. The exact nature of Grendel has long been a source of debate for scholars because his appearance is never directly described in Old English by the original Beowulf poet. Grendel is referred to as a Sceadugenga (“shadow walker” or “night goer”), given that the monster was repeatedly described to be in the shroud of darkness. In the poem Grendel and his mother are described as descendants of the Biblical Cain, the first murderer, and therefore may have something in common with other monsters in the Cain tradition, such as vampires. Seamus Heaney, in his translation of Beowulf, wrote that Grendel was vaguely human in shape, though much larger – his disembodied head, for instance, was so huge that it required four men to transport it. Furthermore, when Grendel’s torn arm is inspected, Heaney describes it as being covered in impenetrable scales and horny growths, much like that of a troll. Tolkien’s translation of Beowulf was much earlier than that of Heaney but, given that they were both working from the same source material, he must also have been aware of the potential troll-like nature of Grendel.

Tolkien’s own trolls, therefore, uniformly had strong bodies and tough skin but dull wits. Indeed, the stupidity of trolls was so great that many could not be taught speech at all, while others learned the barest rudiments of the Black Speech of orcs. But the Dark Lord Sauron made use of them where he could, teaching them what little they could learn and increasing their wits with wickedness. For they made fearsome opponents in battle, most often wielding huge clubs and hammers. Many types of trolls existed in Middle Earth: snow trolls, mountain trolls, hill trolls, cave trolls and others. They were particularly common in the Ettenmoors, the Troll-fells north of Rivendell, where Aragorn’s grandfather met his demise at their hands. Trolls typically lived up in the mountains or in caves and caverns, where they could hide by day from the light of the sun. The exception were the trolls known as Olog-hai, who were bred by Sauron through his foul arts to not only be larger, stronger, swifter and far more cunning than other trolls, but also not to turn to stone in the light of the sun as long as the Dark Lord’s will held sway over them.


Since Tolkien’s time, trolls have been a staple of fantasy literature, as shown by their numerous portrayals in the Harry Potter, Artemis Fowl and Discworld series. They are also a stock villain in role-playing games such as Dungeons & Dragons, Warhammer and World of Warcraft. In both fantasy role-playing games and novels trolls seem to be similar in appearance and behaviour to Tolkien’s – with a couple of major exceptions. In  Memory, Sorrow and Thorn, for example, Tad Williams’ trolls are very different, but arguably just as authentic, as Tolkien’s in both looks and manner. The Qanuc are diminutive, wise and heroic in nature – resembling Inuit tribesmen rather than hulking monsters. This depiction also harks back to Norse mythology, where there seems to have been an element of overlap between the term ‘troll’ and ‘dwarf’, depending on the region of origin of the story. But Scandinavian lore does give a separate name to this smaller troll race, who are sometimes referred to as Huldrefolk (“hidden-folk”). The Huldrefolk are, however, perhaps best thought of as a race apart from the larger, more menacing trolls that inspired Tolkien, terrorised hobbits and no doubt gave nightmares to generations of children from the Viking age to this one.

One Response to “The Race of Twilight”

  1. mirrortac June 15, 2015 at 12:49 pm #

    Reblogged this on The Wizard's Sword and commented:
    I had snow trolls in my original draft of The Wizard’s Sword, but took them out as they had no bearing on my story.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: